Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Nella's avatar

I really enjoyed this article. Thanks very much for writing it. You've articulated well something I've observed over the years, having lived in Paris, majored in French, and taught English to several French students over the years, but I wouldn't have been able to explain so clearly.

This contrast really makes sense as I've considered our flawed American healthcare system. We're largely on our own, as I've discovered firsthand, as we face greedy insurers who don't bat an eye at bankrupting sick people.

The French very likely wouldn't have allowed such a system to become as entrenched as it has in the first place. But even if it was, they'd probably take to the streets and deal with such a situation systemically and collectively. Several of them have been truly mystified that Americans tolerate the worst aspects of our healthcare system.

As I've had to fight back against hundreds of thousands of dollars in crazy wrong medical bills, I've been astonished that so many Americans don't seem to push back at all against insurers. They seem to believe we have the best system in the world. People are amazed I've successfully pushed back and marvel that I even tried. A strong sense of the injustice of it all has informed my actions.

I think you've described a fundamental cultural difference at the root of the dynamic. So interesting.

Liesl Behr's avatar

Pamela, you’ve done it again ! I (secretly ?) love my American self-help books and podcasts. But I’ve also come to recognize that they are primarily a source of dopamine for me. I read or listen and feel so inspired, I see that shiny self out there, and then my « french » self brings me back down to earth. I’d probably have been better off listening to a half-hour history podcast like my husband ! I listen to a few productivity themed podcasts in English, mostly targeted to moms, and I’ve noticed that there’s no french equivalent. The French « mom-casts » that apple suggests are more esoteric…like how to breathe deeply and find inner peace. Peel your potatoes with a deep inner smile. As for the individual vs collective burden l think the French / American mix is ideal. I have lost my taste for the massive scale individualism I experience in the US, and yet I see that a version of that has shaped me deeply in positive ways, and I like to think that I bring that individualistic can-doism to French collectivism and hope that I can pass that on to my child.

61 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?